I feel I should begin by thanking E4 and Picturehouse for creating the magical institution that is Slackers Club because I got to see this a few days before release and for free(!). Me and Earl and the Dying Girl follows Greg (Thomas Mann), who is forced by his mother to go and spend time with Rachel (Olivia Cooke), as she has just been diagnosed with leukemia. This is, as he puts it, the beginning of a “doomed friendship”. Naturally, the two have a rough start but find their way to a funny and wholly watchable friendship. The whole time, Rachel is getting sicker, and Greg is talked into making a film for her with his friend or “coworker” Earl (RJ Cyler). They’re told to make a film because it gets out that the two have been making copies of well-known films by changing the titles of them; Pooping Tom, Sockwork Orange, Senior Citizen Kane and so on. These films then get shown to Rachel and we as an audience, get little, hilarious glimpses at their work. I’ll give you a hint – they’re fantastic.
The best thing about this film, however, is not their parody version ‘My Dinner with Andre the Giant’, but the sheer humour that comes from the films characters. If you’ve met me, you’ll know I have a tendency to dislike a lot of teen characters in film, but here are three fantastic teen characters that I adore. Greg is so self-depreciating but so wonderfully funny and a little odd, that I knew from the start I would enjoy the film. Earl – where do I begin – Earl is hilarious, but secretly kindhearted and very observant of his friend Greg. Rachel is only given so much character as we watch her health deteriorate, but as said in the film, we can learn about people after they die. Now, I won’t ruin it, but one of the best things Rachel does gets found out by Greg at the very end of the film (if you intend to see the film and find out what I mean, the key here is scissors. You’re welcome). What’s amazing about this film is that it’s not just the stars that are good, it’s the parents too. Connie Britton, Nick Offerman and Molly Shannon absolutely shine. I was tempted to say ‘particularly Molly Shannon’ but I mean it when they say they were all excellent. Fans of Nick Offerman will love his strange kimono-wearing, squid-eating, and cat-holding father figure here.
I think the greatness of this film boils down to two things; it’s experimental, and almost Submarine/Ayoade-like use of camera shots and angles, and the script. My Dad is always reminding me about the famous Hitchcock quote; that “[t]o make a great film you need three things – the script, the script and the script”. This film is a testament to that kind of thinking, and as a result the whole audience is engrossed from start to finish, laughing and quite possibly crying as they go.
I expected to enjoy this film, but was definitely surprised at just how much I enjoyed it. It was such a gentle film that I didn’t notice the lengthy two hours it ran on for. The film has gotten a mixture of bad reviews from harsh critics who have tended to be rather condescending to the genre and to the general concept, and very positive reviews from people like myself who was amazed at how cheery (most of) the film turned out to be. I understand the conflict between a large number of people and this wide genre of movies about teens with problems (from a spectrum of cancer-centered films to films about mental health struggles and the little island of John Green adaptations). I won’t lie, a lot of the films suck. I struggle with some of the John Green films and some of the forcibly alternative films that just seem false and don’t work. However, the genre isn’t a total wash-out. If you are willing, there are some that are truly golden; Submarine, The Perks of Being a Wallflower, and Me and Earl and the Dying Girl are well worth a few hours of your time.
This film was surprisingly moving, and just really interesting – I was engrossed from the moment it began. The cast is absolutely spot-on and each character is so rich and well-written that there are no dull moments. It was surprisingly difficult to review this one, but it really was good and I am still a little shocked it was as good as it was. I would recommend watching this if it’s your kind of thing – if it’s not entirely for you, or you’re stingy then wait for the DVD release. I’ll certainly be adding it to my shelf upon release.
Me and Earl and the Dying Girl is a great film, that will keep you entertained for two hours straight. If you’re anything like me (or most domestic animals), then that’s quite impressive, and as a result, earns FOUR STARS.